Financial exclusion can come in many forms, from lack of access to banking to broadband. It affects millions of people in the UK.
These challenges often hit people on low incomes and lead to a poverty premium- paying more for essential products and services because you are on a low income.
For people who have migrated to the UK this is no different. In fact, it can often be worse as they incur an additional set of premiums and challenges as they get to grips with systems and institutions that may be different to the ones they are used to.
Migration Policy Scotland has recently published a report which explores financial disadvantage amongst migrants, who make up over 10% of Scotland’s population. The report shines a light on how migrants in Scotland experience the poverty premium. Across the UK as a whole, 16% of the population are migrants who may experience similar issues.
Not all people migrating to this country are necessarily on a low income, and migrants are not explicitly identified in most poverty statistics. However, it is estimated that 45% of families where parents were born outside the UK are in poverty compared to 24% of families with UK born parents.
Types of poverty premium faced
Migration Policy Scotland’s report emphasises that there is a range of premiums that only affect migrants. Examples of this are visa charges and NHS surcharges which can amount to £20,670 for a family of four in the first four years after arrival. But in other areas essential costs which are high for the population as a whole also effect migrants and they can be excluded from, or find it harder to access, ways of reducing these.
Energy
For people who do not have English as their first language, navigating the energy system can be particularly challenging. People who have recently arrived in the country also do not have a credit file, and therefore often can’t set up a Direct Debit which is frequently the most effective way to access cheaper tariffs. In addition, migrants may struggle to understand the complexities of tariffs – the fact that you pay a standing charge even if you don’t use any energy, for example – or the process of switching supplier. Migrants are very likely to be renting their home, which means they may have to pay by meter. They may also be in energy inefficient accommodation, which they can do little or nothing about.
Car insurance
For many people moving to the UK a car is essential to get to work, to make and maintain friendships and to fully integrate in society. This is especially true in rural Scotland. The cost of converting a non-UK driving license can be prohibitively expensive, and yet the cost of car insurance rises steeply if someone keeps a non-UK driving license.
Credit and digital exclusion
A priority for anyone arriving in the country is setting up a UK bank account, but this can be challenging in terms of showing proof of identity and address. In addition, migrants without a UK credit history can struggle to access affordable credit, as a lack of a credit file automatically labels them as high risk. This can result in high interest rates, creating a credit poverty premium, or even worse, put people at risk of exploitation from illegal money lenders.
People who have recently arrived in the country may only have access to a mobile phone, rather than a laptop or desktop computer, which can make completing digital forms a challenge. Where forms and instructions are presented in complex ways this can make understanding requirements additionally challenging for people whose first language is not English.
Housing
People moving to Scotland from abroad often have very few alternatives to privately rented housing, and many end up in high-cost, low-quality accommodation (40% of migrants live in private rented accommodation compared to 15% of UK born people). Most have no right to apply for council housing, and struggle to access suitable social housing through Scottish housing associations. With fewer options, migrants can be more vulnerable to exploitation by landlords requesting unreasonably high deposits and above average rents for poor quality and badly maintained housing.
Conclusions
Migration Policy Scotland’s report is about more than poverty premiums. It accurately describes how many escape routes from the poverty trap are closed to, or harder to access for migrants. It shows how much harder it is for migrants to cut costs of essentials; increase incomes through employment; and find out about their rights to social security.
Both Fair By Design and Migration Policy Scotland would like to see people with lived experience of migration involved and represented in discussions on energy, insurance and financial inclusion policy that affect them. If your organisation would like to know more about how you can better support people who have recently moved to the UK, please contact Migration Policy Scotland.
The work of Migration Policy Scotland in this area is funded by abrdn Financial Fairness Trust.










